Battery: 80 Wh, 2 hrs (high load, high brightness, 120 Hz) to 19 hrs 40 mins (low load, low brightness, 60 Hz)
The two new handheld gaming computers from Asus, the ROG Xbox Ally and the ROG Xbox Ally X, have been the focus of a lot of controversy. Most of it has to do with the name. They are called Xbox, and are promoted by Microsoft as an Xbox. But they cost much more than the desktop consoles do. "It's too expensive!" xbox fans shout, complaining about Microsoft, which shrugs it off by saying that Asus sets the prices.
As a PC-based gamer, I look at the fuss and don't get it. Is this expensive? The top-of-the-range ROG Xbox Ally X that I tested here is not expensive compared to other handheld gaming PCs. It's almost double the price of its predecessor, but there are clearly more expensive alternatives, and the new model has more memory, double the storage, and of course a new, faster processor.
It has the Xbox name, Xbox-style gamepad, a separate Xbox button, and an Xbox interface. But it's a regular, compact Windows 11 PC just like all the other handheld gaming PCs from Asus, Lenovo, and MSI -- and costs accordingly.
In the Xbox app, running in a new "Full Screen Experience" mode, you can buy Xbox games or sign up for Gamepass. It's not the Xbox dashboard you get on the TV with a console, but the Windows app interface, adapted for mouse control. Regardless, it works well to navigate with the device's D-pad, trackballs, and buttons. Or with the screen's pointer. Even though Microsoft has recently raised prices for Gamepass, it's still a good deal for an active gamer.
However, you can jump out of the Xbox box, head over to Windows desktop, and do whatever you want on the computer. Plug in a mouse, keyboard and external monitor and surf the web, stream movies, run Office, talk to Copilot, edit photos, or cut video. Nothing stops it.
The big stores are even nicely integrated with the Xbox interface. I tried installing some Steam games and they show up (after a reboot) in the Xbox app under "My Games". That makes this the only "Xbox" that can run Playstation games that are otherwise console-exclusive to Sony -- a potential selling point on its own.
Asus and Microsoft have done a great job of kicking you right into the Xbox interface from startup, and after I'm signed up with my Microsoft account, I never really have to leave that interface. There's a quick panel with performance, light, sound, and screen settings that comes up as an overlay.
You can also manage the microphone, Xbox friends list, screenshots, and Gaming Copilot, a beta-stage AI service that will provide strategy tips and recommend new games.
The device is built with high quality materials and provides just the right control. Two extra buttons on the back are unusually small, but well placed. The screen, a seven-inch IPS, is sharp, attractive and produces good colors. There's good contrast, short response times and up to 120Hz frame rate with VRR. Clean and distinct sound from the built-in stereo speakers isn't bad either. But it could be more powerful.
I liked the 8-inch MSI Claw 8 AI Plus I tested this spring, but it has a few more pixels to push on its 1200p screen, which affects performance slightly. And it's a heavier and clunkier machine, so as a whole I prefer the ROG Xbox Ally X which is lighter and more compact -- and more affordable to boot.
So, what about the most important thing, the performance? Is this the handheld gaming machine to beat? Well, AMD Ryzen AI Z2 Extreme gives a slight boost in CPU and graphics performance compared to Ryzen Z1 Extreme, and in some measurements it beats Intel's Arc solution sitting in MSI Claw 8 AI Plus. But is it enough?
When I tested the MSI Claw 8 AI Plus, I complained that a desired performance boost was missing compared to Ryzen Z1 Extreme machines. MSI disagreed and said they had better performance, but the difference is likely due to the games I was testing and not optimizing them with the correct settings. The boost didn't feel as obvious as two years of development should though.
I feel the same here. The Ryzen AI Z2 Extreme performs better in synthetic performance measurements with Geekbench and 3DMark. That makes it a smoother docked desktop PC, but it doesn't immediately convert to better frame rates in games.
Not that it's slow. I test a wide range of games from both Steam and Xbox Gamepass, and can fly around throwing copters in Control, hike Night City in Cyberpunk 2077, and ride around the prairie in Red Dead Redemption 2 with acceptable frame rates and stability of 30 fps or more.
Nothing for a hardcore PC gamer, but at a stable console level -- at least without ray tracing. Less demanding games like Celeste, Hades, and Silksong run with even better results. With Wi-Fi 6e you get a fast connection with little lag, and can stream games via Gamepass Ultimate. Or why not even Geforce Now? As I said, it's a completely open PC.
You can also connect Asus' external graphics card XG Mobile via usb-4 port if you play with the device docked. Then you can get full Xbox Series X-level performance, and play on a 4K TV with high framerates. But that all costs quite a bit extra.
The CPU cores are more energy-efficient than the previous generation, reducing cooling requirements and extending battery life. Total TDP with the graphics circuit lands between 13 and 25 watts on battery or up to 30 watts with a power adapter. You can seamlessly choose between Turbo, Performance, and Quiet modes, with different energy consumption. You can also quickly and smoothly switch between 720p and 1080p resolution to maximize frame rates in games.
It's one thing that Asus and Microsoft have achieved for Xbox fans: Xbox games are so well customized that the need for settings is minimal. I don't know if that's specific to the ROG Xbox Ally X or general to Xbox games on Windows, but it provides a smoother "buy and run" feel than I'm used to. Select the performance mode and resolution in the context menu, and most things are taken care of automatically.
The battery lasts between 90 minutes and 5-6 hours depending on the games I play. Especially for less demanding games, it's clearly more power efficient than previous models. If you want to do something simpler, like streaming a film or surfing, it can last all day without any problems. Obviously, it's the graphics circuit that saps the most energy.