Despite laments from cultural commentators, the book has been remarkably chirpy for a species constantly threatened with extinction.
I've been hearing laments like this all my life, and so far, the book has been remarkably chirpy for a species constantly threatened with extinction. But could the doomsayers be right this time?There's been a flurry of recent articles on this subject, and perhaps the longest and most terrifying jeremiad has come fromwriter James Marriott.
"Welcome to the post-literate society," he says in his Substack newsletter Cultural Capital. He gives us a potted history of the print revolution and how it changed the world. And now, he says, we are living through the counter-revolution. Back to a feudal age. Nothing will ever be the same again. Blimey. He quotes statistics showing that reading is "in free-fall". In the US, reading for pleasure has fallen by 40 per cent in the past 20 years. In the UK, more than a third of adults say they have given up reading. The OECD found recently that literacy levels were declining or stagnating in most developed countries. There are various reasons for this. In Marriott's view, you will not be surprised to hear, the main culprit is the smartphone. But you read stuff on the smartphone, I thought. That's how I read his essay.Ah, says Marriott, but the smartphone demands your entire life. It is designed to be hyper-addictive. "If the reading revolution represented the greatest transfer of knowledge to ordinary men and women in history, the screen revolution represents the greatest theft of knowledge from ordinary people in history." There's plenty of anecdotal evidence from university teachers that the current crop of students can't keep up with the reading load and can't keep track of what they do read. Certain kinds of complex and logical thinking simply cannot be achieved without reading and writing. In other words, we're all being dumbed down., "passively scrolling TikTok or X weakens everything from your ability to process verbal information to your working memory to your ability to focus. You might as well take a sledgehammer to your skull." And he neatly sums up Marriott's argument: "Back in Homer's day, people lived within an oral culture, then humans slowly developed a literate culture. Now we seem to be moving to a screen culture. Civilisation was fun while it lasted."Is the book doomed then, and civilisation with it, and can we do nothing to revive it? Well, for a start these arguments ignore bestselling books read by millions. Are they saying that such books never have any literary merit? Retired book editor Gerald Howard keeps the faith. He points to some of the masterpieces that were ignored or reviled at the time of publication but redeemed by later generations.. "It serves no obvious purpose. It does not feed us or clothe us or, unless you get very lucky, enrich us. But literature is also as close to immortal as any cultural endeavour of humankind has ever been." Another Substack regular, the novelist and short-story writer George Saunders, has a positive spin. He finds it all "kind of exciting ... We're hostile and agitated and divided and mutually suspicious in part because, increasingly, we're using only the shallow, reactive part of our brains., by simply sharing what we know: that reading and writing have the power to make us bigger people."
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Spurs Manager Pleased with Improved Display Despite Defeat, Eyes Fulham Clash for Home WinDespite a 5-3 loss to PSG, the Tottenham manager expressed satisfaction with the team's attacking performance and the integration of young players. With a focus on improving home form and replicating past team dynamics, the team looks forward to the Fulham match.
Read more "
Are the doomsayers right? Are we living in post-literate times?Despite laments from cultural commentators, the book has been remarkably chirpy for a species constantly threatened with extinction.
Read more "
Chris Rogers Backs Victorian Star Fergus O'NeillVictorian coach Chris Rogers compares seamer Fergus O'Neill to Vernon Philander, highlighting his skill and resilience despite lacking express pace, and believes he has the potential for a successful international career.
Read more "
Labor denies job cuts despite public service ballooning by 40,000Finance Minister Katy Gallagher has denied the Albanese government will cut public service jobs as part of its efforts to find savings across departmental budgets.
Read more "
Are the doomsayers right? Are we living in post-literate times?Despite laments from cultural commentators, the book has been remarkably chirpy for a species constantly threatened with extinction.
Read more "
Littleproud refuses to call Joyce a 'rat' despite decision to quit the NationalsNationals leader David Littleproud has refused to call Barnaby Joyce a "rat" despite the former party leader's decision to quit the party he once led.
Read more "